Right along with Left React to the Extension of Warrantless Surveillance

The political news cycle is usually fast, along with keeping up can be overwhelming. Trying to find differing perspectives worth your time is usually even harder. which’s why we have scoured the internet for political writing by the right along with left which you might not have seen.

Has This kind of series exposed you to brand new ideas? Tell us how. Email us at ourpicks@nytimes.com.

For an archive of all the Partisan Writing Roundups, check out Our Picks.

by the Right


The House of Representatives voted on Thursday to extend the National Security Agency’s warrantless surveillance program for six years with minimal adjustments. The agencies headquarters in Maryland.

Brendan Smialowski/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

Jim Banks in The Washington Examiner:

“As a conservative, I am committed to both protecting our national security along with our civil liberties. As a matter of national security, we cannot return to a pre-9/11 footing by reinstituting barriers between national security along with law enforcement.”

Mr. Banks, a Republican congressman by Indiana, explains why he supports the decision by Congress to reauthorize Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. The statute allows the government to continue conducting warrantless searches of communications of foreigners abroad, even when they are talking to American citizens. Mr. Banks argues which the provision is usually an “irreplaceable tool” crucial for the intelligence community to protect the nation. Moreover, he counters arguments which Section 702 compromises the privacy of Americans by explaining which the idea “is usually subject to extraordinary checks along with balances, including oversight by all three branches of government.” Read more »


Willis L. Krumholz in The Federalist:

“The problem, fundamentally, is usually which Congress has given our intelligence agencies too much power, along with refuses to check these agencies even when they flagrantly abuse the vast powers they have been granted.”

Mr. Krumholz cites what he sees as abuses of Section 702 as an argument against reauthorization of the provision. He is usually particularly concerned with the process known as unmasking, wherein government officials can find out the identities of Americans participating in foreign communications picked up by intelligence agencies. Despite their best intentions to prevent terrorism along with crime, he argues, intelligence agencies are not immune by a central tenet of human nature: “Unaccountable power corrupts along with could be abused by even the best of us.” Read more »


by the Left


Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky along with some other lawmakers held a press conference on Wednesday urging adjustments to the N.S.A.’s surveillance authority.

Eric Thayer for The brand new York Times

Alex Shephard in brand new Republic:

“Trump’s FISA tweets betray a deep ignorance of the program, suggesting which he is usually getting his policy briefings not by White House staffers, nevertheless by television.”

Mr. Shephard takes on a particularly odd moment from the battle over the law’s reauthorization when, on Thursday morning, President Trump posted seemingly contradictory Twitter message on the issue. To Mr. Shephard, having the president walk back his initial message against reauthorization was a sign which he was out of step with his own administration. More important, perhaps, the idea also proves which Republican legislators have decided which, on policy, they will just ignore what their party’s leader has to say. Read more »


Trevor Timm in NBC News:

“Democrats should have had the foresight to roll back the Bush-era surveillance laws under President Obama; the idea’s unconscionable to today hand Trump even more leverage to seek retribution along with give him a green light to conduct unconstitutional surveillance on Americans.”

Mr. Timm, the executive director of the Freedom of the Press Foundation, takes aim Democrats who joined with the House speaker, Paul D. Ryan, along with some other Republicans to extend the N.S.A.’s ability to spy on Americans without a warrant. He singles out the House Democratic leader, Nancy Pelosi, along with Representative Adam B. Schiff of California, for being staunch critics of the Trump administration while simultaneously granting the idea more power. Mr. Timm urges Senate Democrats to correct the mistake their colleagues from the House made in Thursday’s vote. Read more »

Continue reading the main story